BOOK REVIEW
Reviewer: Kofi
Akosah-Sarpong in Ottawa, Canada
TITLE: SACRED SPACES AND PUBLIC QUARREL
African Cultural and Economic Landscapes
EDITED BY: Ezekiel Kalipeni and Paul T. Zeleza
PUBLISHER: African World Press, Inc. P.O. Box 48, Asmara,
Eritrea. 2000
PAGES: 370
PRICE: US$50.00
Because of colonialism or the mind of the African elite there of, core African culture
and tradition informing policies and solutions to Africa's problems have for long not
being considered in the larger African scheme of things. In recent times, more so, as the
African Renaissance process increasingly opens up, African cultural and traditional values
are being used as the bedrock of policies and operations, as the weaknesses of mainly
Euro-centric values worsen situations. The South African Truth and Reconciliation
Commission and others emerging in other parts of Africa, like the on-going one in Nigeria,
is informed by the African tradition of healing and shaming. The United Nations secretary
general, Mr Kofi Anan, and the former secretary general of the Commonwealth of Nations, Mr
Emeka Anyakou, have revealed how their global diplomatic policies and operations are
informed by African values of compassion, consensus, co-operation, consideration, and
respect.
In a way this book comes in the wake of the Ghana's George Ayitteh's much trumpeted
"African solutions for African problems." Here African political, economic and
cultural landscapes are opened and discussed, informing us how they can heal much of the
stupidity of today-"sacred spaces and public quarrels." The book is as a result
of papers presented in a symposium by the Center for African Studies at the University of
Illinois, Urbana-Champaign in 1996 themed Space, Culture and Society in Africa. The
editors, Ezekiel Kalipeni, a teacher of geography and African studies at the University of
Illinois and Paul Tiyambe Zeleza, a teacher of history and African studies at the
University of Illinois, say the theme came out of the observations that the rapid and
complex changes that Africa is undergoing cannot be adequately explained by the
conventional and narrowly-focused Eurocentric disciplinary perspectives and approaches.
The case for devising more African value induced complex and integrated inter-disciplinary
paradigms becomes more urgent by the day.
Compelled by this, they conceived the strategic concept of space which they tied up to
physical place, historical process, social reconstruction, and imaginative landscape all
grounded in African culture and tradition. In a way the book reflects the growing
relevance of analytical perspectives in African Studies and the inability of Euro-centric
values uncritically imposed on Africa to adequately explain the nature and dynamics of
African societies and cultures. Progress to use African societies and cultures to explain
Africa's troubles have been limited by intellectual interactions and conversations among
social scientists. The book attempts to solve this problem by bringing together a galaxy
of analysis, research and debate that the African society and culture, for long separated
from each other, to connect disciplinary boundaries, as part of a continuum to hatch
paradigms and research methods to better analyze and explain African histories, societies
and realities.
The first part of the book explains at length the what is 'space' in the larger
existence of the African and his/her culture: an active template of social existence and
constitutive force of society's composition and construction. Space is everywhere, seen
more in production and consumption of material and creative cultures, of the city and the
literary text, of the constitution and representation of bodies, communities, and nations,
and all these take place in both real and imagined geographical and social spaces. We see
more of this in the changing pattern of African cities, which have been called so by
academic tourists who have fixed Euro-centric views of what a "real" city should
be.
This view, for long seen in the legacies of colonialism and modernism and theorizing
the postcolonial patterns and processes of urban change, is changing via the struggle of
different value systems--African and European-- priorities and mechanisms through the
imaginations of and needs of popular African classes to reclaim and re-shape urban spaces
in their own African value images. A key example is the Malawian capital city of Lilongwe
where internal spatial structures were conditioned by authoritarian developmentalist
model, bankrolled and inspired by South Africa and apartheid urban planning. All this, in
the larger African value struggles with European ones, is changing, being increasingly
dictated by African values and reality.
The second part of the book deals with the issue that landscapes are not only economies
and politics, they are ritual, therapeutic and aesthetic spaces: they are cultural and
medical geographies, ecological knowledge, and the spatial dynamics of social ecologies of
gender and disease. We read how there is paradigmatic shift in medical geography in
Africa, from the traditional approaches of cultural ecology to the development of
contextual and meaning-centred perspectives. A typical case is the healing process of the
Kalahari Kung, where there are inter-sections of environment and healing. This is further
seen in Nigeria's Charles Anyinam ( page 147) exploration of the links between
ethno-medicine and ecology, saying that ethno-medical practices, especially the creation
of sacred places, have played, and continue to play, prominent role in the conservation
and preservation of African ecosystems. In the battle between African native medicine,
seen in many an alternative medicine's campaigns today despite the rapid boom in science
and technology, and the Western ones, African ethno-medicine is coming in the forefront,
for long suppressed by colonialism and its subsequent anthropocentric universal religions
and the positivist and material convictions of modernism. Anyinam make a case of the
therapeutic and ecological value of folk cultures and knowledges, grounded in the
African's vision of nature and creation of sacred spaces.
The last section looks at the question of space and artistic production, specifically
between art and space, texts and contexts, autobiography and space. We read more about
this in Nigeria where artists use the notion of "body-space" in their time-lines
of family memorials and artists' representation of sacral objects where the African
inhabit spaces, inscribe value to such spaces, and internalize the articulated systems
within. Added to the above is how the African imagine his nation-state. In Kwaku Larbi
Korang's piece, he explores the spatial history of the African nation. He raises some
questions in the context of the collapse of some African states and the paralysis of
others: "Where did the nation go wrong? Where, then, might it recover ground? A
resolution of these questions hinges on asking still others. Who imagines the nation and
in what capacity? What is invested in this imagining and hence in what terms is the nation
couched? How have circumstances, in allowing the nation to be imagined in certain ways,
also constrained this imagining in certain other ways?" Korang says the answers in
all these questions rest in the cultural project or narrativity and the historical spatial
ordering of the constituent parts of the African nation.
*****